2022 - Present: Courtney J. Ruffner Grieneisen

2015-2021: Alan J. Gravano

2011-2014: George Guida

2009-2010: Josephine Gattuso Hendin

2007-2008: Mary Jo Bona

2003-2006: Anthony Julian Tamburri

2000-2003: Mario Aste
          (Born January 11, 1943; Died February 6, 2019)

1997-2000: Fred L. Gardaphe

1993-1996: Jerome Krase

1989-1992: Richard N. Juliani

1985-1988: Dominic Candeloro

1983-1984: Frank J. Cavaioli

          (Born January 7, 1930; Died November 4, 2022)

1980-1981: Francis X. Femminella

          (Born June 19, 1929; Died October 11, 2009)

1978-1979: George E. Pozzetta

          (Born October 29, 1942; Died May 19, 1994)

1974-1977: Luciano J. Iorizzo

1970-1973: Salvatore J. LaGumina

1966-1969: Rudolph J. Vecoli

          (Born March 2, 1927; Died June 17, 2008)